Astro vs Shopify

A performance-first headless frontend versus the world's leading e-commerce platform. Compare the two approaches to selling online.

Quick verdict: Choose Astro with a headless commerce backend for content-heavy e-commerce where performance and storytelling drive sales. Choose Shopify for traditional online stores that need built-in payment processing, inventory management, and a proven app ecosystem.

Feature Comparison

Feature Astro Shopify
Primary Purpose Website framework (with commerce via integrations) All-in-one e-commerce platform
Page Load Speed Sub-second (static HTML from CDN) 1-3s typical (server-rendered with Liquid)
Payment Processing Via Stripe, Snipcart, or Shopify Storefront API Built-in (Shopify Payments, 100+ providers)
Inventory Management Via headless backend (Shopify API, Medusa, etc.) Built-in with multi-location support
Content Flexibility Unlimited -- blogs, guides, landing pages, any layout Limited to Shopify's page structure and Liquid templates
Design Control Complete (any CSS, any layout) Theme-based (customizable within theme structure)
App / Plugin Ecosystem npm ecosystem + any API integration 8,000+ Shopify apps
SEO Full control over HTML, structured data, speed Good basics; limited URL structure control
Hosting Any host (self-hosted, CDN, cloud) Shopify hosting only
Pricing Free (open source) + hosting + commerce backend $39-399/month + transaction fees

Performance

Astro

  • ✓Static HTML served from edge CDN -- sub-second load times globally
  • ✓Product pages, category pages, and blog posts are all pre-built at deploy time
  • ✓Zero JavaScript by default -- only interactive elements (cart, search) load JS
  • ✓Lighthouse scores of 95-100 are typical for content and product pages
  • ✓Faster page speed has been shown to directly increase e-commerce conversion rates

Shopify

  • ●Pages are server-rendered using Liquid templates on each request
  • ●Shopify's CDN caches assets but dynamic content requires server processing
  • ●Third-party apps frequently inject additional JavaScript on every page
  • ●Lighthouse scores typically range from 40-75 for stores with apps installed
  • ●Performance degrades as more apps and tracking scripts are added

E-commerce Capabilities

Astro (Headless)

Astro is not an e-commerce platform on its own. Instead, it serves as a high-performance frontend that connects to a commerce backend via API. Common pairings include the Shopify Storefront API, Snipcart, Medusa, or Crystallize.

This headless approach gives you total control over the shopping experience. You design the product pages, category layouts, and checkout flow exactly as you want. The trade-off is that you need a developer to build and maintain the integration.

Shopify

Shopify is purpose-built for e-commerce. Out of the box you get product management, inventory tracking, order fulfillment, payment processing, shipping rate calculation, tax handling, and a secure checkout. The admin dashboard handles the full order lifecycle.

The Shopify App Store offers thousands of integrations for email marketing, reviews, subscriptions, dropshipping, and more. For store owners who want everything in one place, Shopify's all-in-one approach is hard to beat.

Pricing

Astro + Headless Commerce

Astro is free. Hosting is free or near-free on static hosts. The commerce backend is the main cost: Snipcart charges 2% per transaction. Shopify Lite (Storefront API only) is $9/month. Medusa is open source and self-hosted.

The primary investment is developer time for the initial build and ongoing feature development. For stores where content marketing and SEO drive significant traffic, the performance advantages can generate strong ROI.

Shopify

Shopify Basic starts at $39/month. Shopify standard is $105/month. Advanced is $399/month. Transaction fees range from 2.4-2.9% + 30 cents per sale unless you use Shopify Payments. Premium themes cost $180-350 as a one-time purchase.

Apps add up quickly: email marketing ($10-30/month), reviews ($10-50/month), loyalty programs ($20-100/month). A typical store with 5-10 apps can easily spend $100-300/month in app fees on top of the Shopify subscription.

Best Use Cases

Choose Astro + Headless for

  • →Content-driven e-commerce (blogs, guides, storytelling)
  • →Brands where page speed and Core Web Vitals impact organic traffic
  • →Custom shopping experiences with unique design requirements
  • →Businesses that already have a Shopify backend but want a faster frontend
  • →Companies with developer resources to build and maintain the storefront

Choose Shopify for

  • →Traditional online stores with standard product catalogs
  • →Businesses that need payment processing, shipping, and tax handling built in
  • →Teams without developers who need to manage products independently
  • →Dropshipping and print-on-demand businesses
  • →Multi-channel selling (online, in-store, social media, marketplaces)

Our Verdict

Shopify is the industry standard for online stores -- and for good reason. It handles payments, inventory, shipping, taxes, and order management in a single platform. For businesses that want to start selling quickly without custom development, Shopify provides a proven, reliable foundation.

Astro paired with a headless commerce backend (including Shopify's own Storefront API) is the better choice when your e-commerce strategy depends on content marketing, organic search, and conversion-focused design. The performance difference is meaningful: faster pages lead to lower bounce rates and higher conversion rates. Studies consistently show that even a 100ms improvement in page load time can increase revenue.

For content-heavy brands where the website is a marketing engine -- not just a product catalog -- Astro's performance advantages make a measurable impact on the bottom line. For straightforward e-commerce stores, Shopify's all-in-one platform is the more practical choice.

Ready to Build with Astro?

Let us help you choose the right platform and build a website that performs.

Get My Free Platform Assessment